|
Life
[ top ] Works
[ top ]
[ top ]
[ top ] Criticism
[ top ] Commentary
Douglas Dunn: [Simmons] writing denies imagination its rights, and language its sensuousness. His meaning is that the domestic must triumph above all else (The Speckled Hill, the Plovers Shore, Encounter, Vol. XLI, No. 6, Dec. 1963, p.74; quoted in Terence Brown, Northern Voices,Dublin: Gill & Macmillan 1975, p.191). Frank Ormsby calls Simmons a refromer or secular evangelist who is firmly on the side of life and freedom, his work pitting theory against personal experience and human fallibility, especially in the areas of love, sex, marriage, the family, growing old. (Intro., Poets from the North of Ireland, 1979.) [ top ] Anthony Cronin greeted the Selected James Simmons as my book of the year ... he is one of the three or four most exciting poets to have emerged from any quarter of Ireland, Scotland, England, or Wales during the last twenty years or so ... [See Blackstaff catalogue, 1980.] [ top ] Patricia Craig, History and its Retrieval in Contemporary Northern Irish Poetry: Paulin, Montague and Others, in Elmer Andrews, ed., Contemporary Irish Poetry: A Collection of Critical Essays (London: Macmillan 1996): Among the Ulster poets, James Simmons is the one least possessed [116] by a feeling for the past and its bearing on the present (unless its his own past: in Simmons, you could say, the historical impulse is subsumed under autobiography.) When he does turn his attention to an object of antiquity, Simmons in fact reverses the procedures of those who go in for reclamation; with this author, it is always the present that imposes itself. [Writes of his From the Irish poems, bang up to date with references to up-market adulteries and a policeman shot in banal circumstances.]; succinct, spontaneous, and without undertones: the thing is happening at the moment, as far as Simmons is concerned, and needs no analogical accompaniment to make an impact. Simmons is demotic and accessible [...]. (pp.116-17.) [ top ] Katie Donovan, interview with James Simmons and Janice Fitzpatrick: The Hedgeschool of Portmuck: Are creative writing courses a scam or an inspiration? The Poets House in Antrim impresses the initially skeptical [KD] (Irish Times 8 August 1995): At Queens and Coleraine they assume that what we are doing is a scam, I was surprised to encounter this level of hostility. I though there might be indifference, but not this level of suspicion ... The teachers at Poet House are working poets who pass on what they know. How can this be a bad thing? Donovan cites Theo Dorgan as calling it the hedge-school of Portmuck, and concludes that it would be churlish to criticise a haven where the art can be nourished. Bernard ODonoghue is an examiner. [ top ] Brian Lynch notices Elegies, with works of other poets, Irish Times (24.2.1996), p.8, quoting from the Preface to the effect that the author looks forward to the day when I find a publisher who will reprint all the old books ... It is fortunate that small presses appear with humility and enthusiasm to save old heroes and foster younger talents; highly commends Elegy for a Deadborn Child, in which craft is married to felt subject; considers the whole not a major book. [ top ] Peter Pegnall, James Simmons, who has died aged 68, was a cavlier poet with an indelible puritan streak. in a time of specialists, he was also a master of many crafts: singer, songwriter, critic, playwright, teacher, entrepreneur, half-decent artist, and wizard of the frying pan at 3 am. [... &c.] further, Simmons [developed] an uncomfortable ability to focus on domestice interiors - things we would rather not talk about. For him, making horrible mistakes was not a denial of humanity, but a part of it [quotes balad of a Marriage]. (Poet Who Nurtured the Writers of Ireland North and South, obituary in The Guardian, Tuesday 10 July 2001.) [ top ] The Irish Times, Obituary Notice (30 June 2001): Simmons brought an anarchic humour and sexual frankness to the often austere moods of Ulster verse; turned sonnet into popular and accessible frorm; unique voice in Irish letters; Honest Ulsterman; Claudy commemorates victims of 1972 bombing; From the Irish, title poem of collection of 1985, show a poet whose sense of wider political and social realities is memorable, acute and strident. [ top ] Martin Mooney, James Simmons 1933-1001: An appreciation, Fortnight, 397 (July/Aug. 2001), p.33: Though often thought of as a contemporary and conederate of tha Belfast Group of heaney, Longley and Mahon, [Simmons] was slightly older than all three and his literary allegiances were significantly different; shared with the Hobsbaum Group (and with his friend Tonyharrison) an adherence to the traditional shapes of verse, the well-made poem, but his love of song made for a solider vision of the public life of poems and poetry. Cites his Ballad of Claudy; quotes Edna Longley: art and life never look like becoming polite strangers. Their intimacy declares itself through the effortlessly natural tones of the poets voice - at once source and focus of the the pervasive vitality. Speaks of his founding of Honest Ulsterman, and of his establishing Poets House with Janice Fitzpatrick - an unparalleled process of discovery for its participants, and often for Simmons himself, who has an undogmatic, open and again, generous approach to the style and intelligence of other poets. Cites his literary-editorship of Fortnight in the 1980s; writer in residence (QUB); Poems 1956-1986 incl. a number of New Poems written during this difficult period of his life; self-ironising. [Cont.] [ top ] Martin Mooney (James Simmons 1933-1001: An appreciation, 2001): Unquestionalbly Simmons work was over-shadowed by the attention awarded to the poems of Heaney and Mahon, and the collections of the 1990s ... try to consolidate the old and new, and occasionally strike notes of bitter self-justification: Simmons saw himself, as he had seen the late John Hewitt, as a [s]ort of Prospero, unjustly exiled. Further: But the democratic wit, sceptical voice of the singer, sure of the value and validity of the everyday, the rich significance of the lived life, remains. Mooney considers it too early to attempt a full literary evaluation but urges that the expansive, discursive later poems ... demonstrate his continual readiness to reconnoitre styles outside his immediate inheritance. Finally: From a protestant [sic] background, and defensive of his tribe, his was nevertheless a secular not a tribal imagination, and if he does not fit easily into the anthologies and readers guides to Irish poetry, then it is our notion of that poetry that must change. [...]. (Note that the Appreciation has no by-line though ascribed to Mooney in the table of contents.) [ top ] P J. Kavanagh writes an appreciation of James Simmons, in Bywords (Times Literary Supplement, 1 Feb. 2000): Simmons fnd. Poets House in 1990 with Janice Fitzpatrick, his third wife; For a politically disengaged man (in his own opinion), he certainly engaged himself in the cultural life of his native Province, and invited others to share it; it was probably that which made him enemies there. Quotes Winter 1991: I was hit / by distant blows of malicious gossip, along / or with Janice. Why? For asking one / why he gave grants of public money to his mistress / for books she did not write? For failing to employ / or flatter bad poets? [...] I thought life /was too short for lies. Too bloody virtuous / I was, too vain, too beautiful - and calls it Simmons at his late-night loosest. Also quotes From the Irish and and Ulster Says No [see under Quotations, infra]. Kavanagh remarks: On the whole, although his aim is to redeemed his Province, his tradition, from itself - by telling the truth of all things! - his subject is himself and his private life, and further remarks that too much detail [about sex] seems an aesthetic mistake. [ top ] Quotations From the Irish, Familiar things you might brush against or tread / Upon in the daily round, were glistening red / With the slaughter the hero caused, though he had gone. / By proxy his bomb exploded, his valour shone. [See Peter Fallon & Derek Mahon, eds., Contemporary Irish Verse, Penguin 1990). [ top ] Ballad of a Marriage: We stayed together out of shame / and habit, and then the children came. /.../ As greens hoots through harden4ed soil / where nothing seemed ot be, / so tenderness, caresses, jokes / grew out of her and me. // No families wave, no organs play, / this long and gradual wedding day. (Quoted in Peter Pegnall [obituary], The Guardian, Tuesday 10 July 2001.) Also, Claudy: An exposion too loud for your eardrums to bear / And young children squealing like pigs in the square / And all faces chalf-white and streaked with bright red, / And the glass and the dust and the terrible dead. [ top ] The Conservative, Time now to consider knickers ...; go easy, love, on the reformed old sexist, his agonies/of withdrawal, the long effort; If this is liberty/to fuck and be fucked/in puritan simplicity/I am a counter-revolutionary; When your old conservative dies/before you, dry your blue eyes; The Provos may not know/themselves from the Stickies,/If in eternity no one bickers/over old hurtful distinctions,/if nothing that mattered matters/and nobody wears knickers. (Printed in A. Carpenter and P. Fallon, eds., The Writers: A Sense of Place, 1980.) [ top ] Intrusion on the Idyll (in Mainstream), Beautiful masks - our island with its thirty shades of green/iots browns, its sunset gold/the rat holes, corpses, shrieking gulls, bones, old combative nature, hungry, angry, dirty/Nature; The nature of life to be dual;/hospitable, voluble, musical ... and superstitious;/slow, enduring intelligent ... and vicious./I hear the cries of my people, wrong and cruel./So are the English./So are we all./The lights/of home draw us smiling to the green and pleasant land, the barren high bog, the picturesque peasant, bowing to the clergy, voting for ignorant shites. (p.14.) [ top ] From the Irish: Most terrible was our hero in battle blows:/hands without fingers, shorn heads and toes / were scattered. That day there flew and fell / from astonished victims eyebrow, bone and entrail,/like stars in the sky, like snowflakes, like nuts in May,/like a meadow of daisies, like butts from an ashtray. //Familiar things you might brush against or thread / upon in the daily round, were glistening red / with the slaughter our hero caused, though he had gone. / By his proxy bomb exploded, his valour shone. (Quoted in P. J. Kavanagh, Bywords, Times Literary Supplement, 1 Feb. 2000.) [ top ] Ulster Says No: One Protestant Irishman/wants to confess this: /We frightened you Catholics, we gerrymandered, / we applied injustice. // However, we werent Nazis or Yanks, / so measure your fuss / who never suffered like Jews or Blacks, / not here, with us; // but, since we didnt reform ourselves, / since we had to be caught red-handed, justice is something / we have to be taught. (Quoted in P. J. Kavanagh, Bywords, Times Literary Supplement, 1 Feb. 2000.) Note that Kavanagh also cites ten lines of Simmons poem From the Irish [most terrible our hero in battle blows] in Voices in Ireland, 1994, p.6.) [ top ] Ulster novels (The Recipe for all Misfortunes, Courage: A Study of Three Works by Ulster Protestant Authors [Forrest Reid, Joyce Cary and Sam Hanna Bell], in Across the Roaring Hill: The Protestant Imagination in Modern Ireland - Essays in Honour of John Hewitt, ed. Gerald Dawe & Edna Longley (Belfast: Blackstaff 1985). pp.79-98: [...] Forrest Reid, Joyce Cary, Sam Hanna Bell: three Protestant names are worth dwelling on. At a time when Ulster Protestants lack leadership, when thoughtful Protestants remain embarrassed because Terence O'Neills attempt to apologise for misrule and set things to rights proved to be more than we would let him deliver, when we must feel like very poor and distant representatives of the great reforming movement that beagan with Luther, there is some encouragement in finding that Protestant novelists have been covering the situation, keeping some sort of flame alive. [...; 81] You get in these novels what you would expect from common Ulster experience: that such human leaps forward as we are likely to have come from individuals, not from any of the Churches. Yet the individuals who bolster and support their weaker brethren have some sort of faith and a belief in something greater than themselves. The Protestant experience offers the best paradigm of this because it is central to the ethos that the individual should reach beyona the Church to God: to some positive image, created by men at the height of their imagination that embodies permanent [97] truth and inspiration, like the life of Christ. In a barbarous time when we have lost touch with our inspirational past, and the way back is barred by dead forms, fallible human beings still stumble forward by instinct, sometimes. / It seems to me that these three books are inspirational; in each case the compassion, energy and passion of the author presents the dark material of reality beautifully, humanely, cogently. (pp.81-97; for full text, see RICORSO Library, Irish Critical Classics, attached.) [ top ] The Trouble with Seamus, in Elmer Andrews ed., Seamus Heaney, Collection of Critical Essays (London: Macmillan 1992), pp.39-66: Simmons asks himself if he is not a Cassius figure resentful of a local Caesar and proceeds to demolish revered poems by Heaney for their sentimentality and incompetence, focusing on the element of nationalist suffering to which he thinks Heaney groundlessly pretends. Note, this article is characterised as the button-holing manner of Simmons by Gerald Dawe, in Linen Hall Review (Autumn 1993). [ top ] Contested nationality: Nationality preoccupies people when it is contested. One is not surprised that Yeats and Joyce, in their different ways, were very conscious of being Irish, and the post-rebellion writers like OConnor felt they had a specifically Irish task to perform. By Becketts time the sense of nationality is secure enough to be ignored. Northern writers must still be confused in this area whether they are in favour of the political link with Dublin or London. The problem can seem at the same time trivial and inescapable. One can hardly be drawn towards either political set-up very strongly. Any solution that would stop the killing would suit, perhaps; but that sort of feeling can hardly speak with passionate intensity. There is no unjust monster to be endured and resisted; but the uncomfortable knowledge that we and our immediate ancestors have burnt our collective backside, and we must sit on the blister. / I am not sure there is anything common to these ten poets apart from their being Irish; but that means that they have experienced the matter of Ireland first hand, speak or have spoken with an Irish accent, come in contact with Gaelic and read translations. I suspect most of them have read Yeats, Joyce, Synge, Beckett, OCasey, Kavanagh, MacNeice, and Flann OBrien with peculiar inwardness and intensity. [... &c.] (Introduction, Ten Irish Poets, 1974, p.9; quoted in Terence Brown, Northern Voices, 1975, p.186.) [ top ] History lessons: [...] it gradually became apparent that the history of the English in Ireland was one of cruel exploitation to which ones first reaction must be, Brits Out; that Northern Ireland had no business to exist. However the evidence for this opinion came slowly, and with it came the confusing evidence that free Irishmen had produced a state even worse than Northern Ireland, where books and plays were banned, where there was no Health Service and where the Catholic Church had inordinate power to inhibit freedom and progress. [...] By the time I came to think of Northern Ireland as a place to live rather than to get out of, the positive thing seemed to be that Northern Ireland should discover socialism, rather than that it should join the even more backward South. By the time I knew something of the history of Ireland I knew that the Irish people had tried and failed. They had produced a few good writers, but were not in any vanguard. (p.24.) [ top ] John McGahern, Amongst Women (1990), in Linen Hall Review (Summer 1990), p.32: I have carried the torch for McGahern since I read The Barracks twenty years ago ... The Dark had power all right [but] much less intellectual distinction [than Joyces Portrait] ... two novels that followed were neither here nor there ... frankly embarrassing passages ... three books of short stories ... had half a dozen pieces even better than The Barracks ... there was no better writer of prose fiction in Ireland. [...] Holding to this position makes the critics enemies. I only began to realise in the last ten years that there is a growth industry called Irish writing and it is kept going by all the published Irish writers either praising each other or shutting up. This works well for everybody [...; for further, see under McGahern, supra.] [ top ] Neil Jordan, Sunrise with Sea-Monster (1995), reviewed in Spectator (Jan. 1995): Simmons professes to be unable to read it; condemns The Crying Game as a remake of OConnors Guest of the Nation, with black and transvestite thrown in. [ top ] Poetry Ireland (with Gabriel Fitzmaurice, Paul Muldoon, and John Hughes), reviewed in Linen Hall Review (Autumn 1993): Simmons writes fulsomely of Muldoon as a genius of more than modest intelligence, tricksy and teasy as well as brilliantly in touch with the surface of modern life and parenthetically dismisses Francis Stuart (whose novels I cant stand), but quotes a full stanza of Berlin 1944. Anthony Cronin, The End of the Modern World, review in Linen Hall Review (1990): technically its as easy as snedding turnips if you have the gift but what a relief to have a poet interested in such interesting matters .... [ top ] References Peter Fallon & Seán Golden, ed., Soft Day, a miscellany of contemporary Irish Writing (Notre Dame/Wolfhound 1980), What Will You Do, Love?; Cavalier Lyric; The End of the Affair; Stephano Remembers. [ top ] Andrew Carpenter & Peter Fallon, eds., The Writers: A Sense of Place (Dublin: OBrien Press 1980), incls. The Conservative [poem in 5 pts.], pp.196-200. Seamus Deane, gen. ed., The Field Day Anthology of Irish Writing (Derry: Field Day 1991), Vol. 3, selects from Energy to Burn, The Silent Marriage; from The Long Summer Still to Come, Didnt He Ramble; from Poems 1956-1986, Ulster Says Yes [1357-59; 1432-33, BIOG & WORKS [as above]. [ top ] Patrick Crotty, ed., Modern Irish Poetry: An Anthology (Belfast: Blackstaff Press 1995), selects “One of the Boys” [191]; “West Strand Visions” [192]; “From the Irish” [193]. Hibernia Books (1996) lists At Six OClock in the Silence of Things: Festschrift for James Simmons (Lapwing/Poets House 1993). [ top ] Notes [ top ] Tom Kinsella: Michael Smith, reviewing Derval Tubridy, Thomas Kinsella, The Peppercannister Poems (2000), in The Irish Times (27 Jan. 2001), notes that James Simmons, inter alia, resented Thomas Kinsellas interfering in a Northern situation with his response to Bloody Sunday Butchers Dozen. John Montague dedicates the poem Fairy Fort to Ben Simmons, the son of James Simmons and Janice Fitzpatrick: As an immense privilege / he is brought down / to the underground hall / where all the giants / have been slumbering / since Times beginning [...] Rascally, he cannot resist / a boastful hallowing [...] (Smashing the Piano, Gallery Press, 1999, p.16.) [ top ] Derek Mahon dedicated Afterlives to James Simmons; the poem concludes with the the sentiment, What middle-class twits we are / To imagine for one second / That our privileged ideals / Are divine wisdom, and that the dim / Forms that kneel at noon/In the city not ourselves, and ending, Perhaps if I had stayed behind / And lived it bomb by bomb / I might have grown up at last / And learnt what is meant by home. (Selected Poems, 1991, pp.50-51; and note cunts for twits in the first book-printed version.) Note Simmons reviewed John Montague and Derek Mahon in a essay which dilates on Mahons private life and his troubles with drink as well as the warmth of his personal poetry (Linen Hall Review, Spring 1994), pp.18-20. [ top ] Michael Longley dedicates a poem, White Water, to James Simmons in his collection Snow Water (Cape 2004): We should have been fat jolly poets / In some oriental print [...]. Brendan Kennelly quotes Claudy: a Ballad, Simmons poem on the IRA bombing at the town of that name, in Poetry and Violence, in Joris Duytschaever and Geert Lernout, eds., History and Violence in Anglo-Irish Literature [Conference of 9 April 1986; Costerus Ser. Vol. 71] (Amsterdam: Rodopi 1988), 5-27; pp.13-14. [ top ] Letterhead: Letterhead of The Poets House in 1995 cites Janice Fitzpatrick and Janes Simmons; 80 Portmuck Road, Portmuck, Islandmagee, Co. Antrim, BT40 3TP, Northerin Ireland; also Advisory Panel: John Farleigh, Dr James Hawthorne CBE, medbh McGuckian, Joan Newman, Frank Ormsby (Northern Ireland); Prof. David Craig, Pamela Gillilan (England); Thomas McCarthy,Gabriel Rosenstock [Chairman of Poetry Ireland] (Ireland); Dr. David Keller, Dr. Sherod Santos, Jean Valentine (USA). [ top ] Portmuck blues: refused planning application at Islandmagee due to objections of local councillors to the sex on train theme of a poem in his collection Mainstream, sent anonymously to a councillor called Bobby McKee; UUP councillor Roy Beggs, former chair of NE Education and Library Board, proposed that the book should be banned in schools; Simmons, speaking from Galway, said that it has been one of my lifelong ambitions to help release Ulster people from guilt and furtiveness over sex. The poem that he is talking about describes a married couple who make love - triumphing over the filth and dirtiness of the Northern Railways toilet to produce joy and happiness. He instanced a tradition stretching from Solomon to Sappho and from John Donne to Blake, Robert Burns, D. H. Lawrence, and James Joyce. Simmons is the grandson of Sir Frederick Simmons, a Presbyterian lord mayor of Derry; the poets house has four MA students from America, Scotland, and Ireland. (Irish Times, Sat. 20 April, Home News, p.5). [ top ] Warned off: Elegies noticed in Books Ireland, First Flush (Feb. 1996, p.36), indicating that the editors were recently warned off Simmons by a not entirely literate letter from a clerical gentleman, which had of course the reverse effect. (Vide the Islandmagee affair of 1996.) Ulsterman Publications - which first published Tom Paulin, et al. - had an address at 70 Eglantine Ave., Belfast BT9 6DY. [ top ] Zorba?: Kyle Magee, the Zorba of the North, in Michael Foleys novel The Road to Notown (1996), is thought to be based on Simmons, whose second wife Imelda Foley may also be a model for a character of this largely autobiographical novel.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||